“It’s Not a Lie if You Believe It”

I received a confrontational phone call from Scott. He is my youngest manchild. I have four grown children. They will always be my kids, and I refer to them as such, but after a certain point, it seems weird to affix a label to them that evokes pictures of them in their youth. So for clarity’s sake, it might be helpful for you to know that he is the only one of my offspring who has yet to hit forty.

I’m not sure if the call was prompted by Artemis II going to the moon last April or if it came organically out of the fact that he and his wife are devoted dog owners, but the conversation went something like this:

Scott – Hey, Mom, wasn’t our dog PJ supposedly named after the first dog in space?

PJ

Me with hesitation – Uhhhhh, well yeah. We named him Pushinka and called him PJ.

Scott – So you know that’s not true. Pushinka wasn’t the first dog in space.

Me – Yes, I know. Later I found out that the original Pushinka was merely the pup of one of the early Russian dogs who orbited earth safely. He’d never been to space himself. He must have been teased by all the other Russian dogs – the butt-sniff of jokes, so to speak.

Scott – So you lied to us all these years. (I think I heard his head shaking back and forth in disapproval.)

Me – Technically yes, but that was before google. I was relying on my memory, plus I liked the name. To quote George Costanza, “It’s not a lie if you believe it.” I believed it.

I know I have shaken my manchild’s belief in me and justified it with a Seinfeld quote, but that’s parenting.

In honor of Father’s Day, let me throw my husband under the bus of lies along with me.

When we were raising our kids, we would often go to the baseball card store or Walmart and buy baseball cards. They would rip open the packs hoping to find one of the big named players of the times or a Baltimore Oriole – that was our family’s team going back a few generations.

One day one of our kids pulled a B J Surhoff card out of the pack and asked their dad what B J stood for. “Brian James,” Bob answered without a second thought, and we all went on our merry way.

Years later one of our sons confronted his dad declaring that B J did not stand for Brian James, but it stood for William James (Billy James, hence B J).

“But you said it with such confidence,” he stated. “Did you just make it up out of thin air?”

“Yep,” Bob answered. “If you say it with enough confidence, people will believe you.”

Well, kids, let that be a lesson to you. I’m not sure what that lesson is, but to this day we often call, “B J Surhoff” on Bob when he declares something a little too emphatically.

For the next lie, I have to tell you that I don’t remember this, but our oldest son swears it’s true. Early in life when he asked me what the BP in BP Gas Stations stood for, apparently, I told him Beatrix Potter. He believed that for years. Like I said, I don’t remember this, but it sounds like me.

I did construct a rather bold-faced lie that was a family story. I told the kids that their dad was really Superman. Bob could do or fix anything, and he was an excellent father and provider. He was and still is a jack of all trades and a master of many. I argued with the kids that they had never seen their dad and Superman in the same place. That was my main proof. Bob was always up before the crack of dawn to go to work, or possibly to take down a super villain. How were they to know!

Bob has received Superman coffee mugs, Superman t-shirts, and even Superman boxers to further back up our claim. I’m sticking with my story, and even if it is a lie – and I’m not saying it is – it’s a good one.

Happy Father’s Day to Bob and my sons and son-in-law and all you fathers out there. May all your lies be fun and silly ones that entertain your families for years to come.

Bob and our kids – Yellowstone, 1995

The Family Secret

Time reveals the effect your words have on others.  As I spent the day with Ella, my nearly seven-year-old granddaughter whose picture is above, she let me in on how my words had affected her.  It all started many years ago, before Ella was even thought of.

When I was a young mother, I tried to find ways to encourage the kids to respect their dad.  Kids are so oblivious to all fathers do for them; it helps to point things out.  One night as we finished our dinner I told the kids they had to remain at the table because it was time to tell them the family secret.  They were alive with anticipation (or were they complaining because they wanted to go outside and play, either way they were a captive audience).

I glanced at my husband at the other end of the table and then I began, “Kids, you are about to hear something so incredible you may not believe it, so before I tell you, you must promise never to tell anyone what you are about to hear.”

They promised and then I told them, “Your father is Superman.”

They had disbelief in their eyes, but I explained how they never see their dad and Superman in the same place.  Dad wears glasses.  He likes to help people.  I went on and on about him, but I don’t think they really believed me.  Since I never cracked a smile and was not in the habit of lying to them, it gave them something to think about.

Flash forward to Father’s Day this year.  We had all of our children and our six grandchildren over and I felt it was time for the grandkids to know the truth about their “Bumpa.”

I brought a wrapped present to the table.  Bob opened it and revealed a Superman coffee mug.  With that on display I said, “Kids, I think you’re old enough now to handle our family secret.”  I made them raise their right hands and promise never to divulge this to anyone.  The kids being 9, 6, 5, 4, and 3 (we didn’t make the two-month-old raise her hand) were happy to comply.  I poured it on good, and their wide eyes revealed that they believed every word.  I explained how it only looks like Bumpa is going to play golf or working.  Often times he is out saving people.

Bob (Bumpa) just sat there receiving their admiration.  They asked him questions and he told them just like he told our children, you never see me and Superman together.  Now you know why.

I had no idea how seriously these words were taken.  My daughter Dena informed me that her kids were asking if she also had superpowers – it only stood to reason that she would.  She told them they were not ready to know the truth just yet.

So back to Ella.  She was over the other day and asked where Bumpa was.  I told her he was playing golf.  She moved close to me and whispered, “You mean he’s out saving someone, don’t you.”

She thinks about this all the time.  She asked me if I had superpowers and I had to admit that I do not.  “I’m more the Lois Lane type,” I explained.

To top things off, I took Ella to run errands with me recently and she told me, “Grandmom, I almost told our secret!  I came so close, but you’d be proud of me because I didn’t.”

I will never forget that conversation.  I hugged Ella tightly and was tempted to tell her my secret, the one where I made up the whole thing, but I couldn’t bring myself to burst her bubble.  So please, if you see my grandkids, keep my secret safe.  Thank you.